Brother Mine,
I've given up your dream. It was never really mine -- I saw too clearly past it for it to be -- but for a while I could at least pretend. I pretended that we were trying to build a future that was not safe merely from demons from without, but from our very personal monsters as well, the ones we see in the streets. The ones we live beside. The ones that live within some of us. The irony is that I still live there -- at least some of the time -- and you do not. You have found safety in a town too small to ever become a city, in the fog and the cry of seabirds. Or a keep, also befogged and usually quiet other than the howling of wolves and the work of men. I envy you. I cannot bear living here all of the time, for more reasons than one, but I can no longer leave for good, not while I am chained here, and for more reasons than one.
I know what laces the mortar in this city, and I no longer can even pretend to dream the dream that it could be cleansed. The rot is too deep. For whose sake would I be pretending anyhow? Almost all are dead or fled, and I'm tired of lying about such things.
You know personally how old the stones are in certain parts of the city. The city was razed to the foundations but some parts were below the foundation. The stones are full of chill, water seeping like tears between them. The worst were consigned here. Back before this was our city, when the orcs swept over, a simple decision was made.
If you had been the gaoler, would you have thrown in the key before you fled the city? Or would you have left them to the invading Horde? I think you would have given them a chance at better than what they faced from the Horde.
I do not know what I would have done. I could not know unless I was there, with the key in my hand. I wonder now ... I sleep so often too near the Stockade. If the alarm bells were ringing, the Horde or the Legion sweeping down on the city, would I think of them? Would I have mercy? Or would I think only of my own? That's not something I can know outside of the moment.
Thieves and murderers, they were left behind bars. Some of them survived, won free, at great cost.
She told me this, though not in words. She gave me a piece of rock, and a number, which turned out to be the number of a cell. At the time its occupant was named Ryland, her name. The rock fit a gap in the wall. From there I could learn the rest, that some survived. That they named themselves revenants, because of what was done to them. That they swore undying revenge on the city. In more than one way they have achieved it, too. They've proven elusive, but they've left a bloody trail.
She is too young to have been in that jail, but I think she was raised behind those bars, with the Horde closing in, regardless of where her actual rearing took place. Raised for vengeance, and to carry the fight on past their lives. I believe that they took haven in Alterac, either as part of the Syndicate or coexisting with them, and they raised their children, and they dreamed of revenge. These are the real dreams that Stormwind engenders. The dreams carved in stone, and the blood in the mortar between those stones. I don't know if she visits now to enact that revenge, or for reasons of her own. It almost seems as if she cares more about discord than about revenge. She cares about having freedom to act, to break free of all restrictions. I think she is still an instrument of revenge, however, whatever her goals.
I don't know what brought her friend Baydon Ardinn to the Council, though I know what broke him from them. I don't know what brought them together, though I believe I met him before I ever met her, and possibly before he met her. It seems that there was a time that he was not on whatever strange path it is that he pursues, though he fell in with them early on. Did they corrupt him? Or did he come to them corrupt already? There is more than one way that a paladin may fall.
I have also finally made a declaration: their interference in my life, and the lives of those who touch me, is no longer something I can tolerate, whatever their motivations. She has seemed fascinated by my friend the paladin, to the point where she has put spells on him and tried to alter him from himself. She turned her attention to me, then, and made similar attempts.
She has found a curious stone which either came in with the Exodar, or is formed when the Draenei ship impacts upon a new world; she calls it "starfall ore" no doubt due to its otherworldly origin. This ore has the ability to grant visions, though it does not seem intrinsically magical in nature -- it may have powerful alchemical properties, but I have never had enough to experiment, or the ability to experiment safely with it. Fused into glass, it is able to grant visions by proximity alone, even when sealed within an airtight box; she gave me a small piece of it and it began to affect my dreams. Touching it would seem an even poorer idea, which is borne out by the advice of a Draenei shaman and jeweler whom I consulted. He thinks it would be very dangerous to touch the glass made from this stone.
So when Baydon forced me to inhale some dust which he ground from a piece of it, I was in dread at what the results would be. And rightfully so; the nightmares still follow me despite all of my attempts to shed them. Worse, I have come to realize that the nightmares are true. It is only a matter of time before what I see will come to pass, and at my hands. It would be easier to not know this, and to let it come when it comes, and to have some peace before it happens. That is what they have robbed me of.
But nightmare or dream, it is something which I cannot run away from, and would not even if I could. We need this to come to pass. Let Stormwind be Stormwind, rotten to the core. Lordaeron has been purged by Scourge and plague, its survivors winnowed terribly until only the hardiest remain. There will be nothing left when we retake it, and we should not make the mistakes that Stormwind did: we should tear stone from stone until not even foundations remain. No hidden cells, no oubliettes. Perhaps we should even rebuild Lordaeron elsewhere.
And in the New Lordaeron, we will pay our debts. If we cannot afford stonemasons, then we will live under thatch until we can.
I think you would approve of that.
Whatever I may be, I pay my debts in full.
And so now she has breathed some of the dust herself. My retribution or recompense. I do not know what she saw, though it harrowed her, and even changed her for a time. It seemed to put her into the past. Still fairly formidable, even at a loss and without context or knowledge, still able to place herself. Perhaps I should have exploited her weaknesses, but it seemed that I had done enough by sharing with her the cruel enlightenment she had forced upon me. My teacher would call me a fool for letting her go, for not using her to the hilt.
So be it, I am a fool.
But I have paid her in kind, at least. And I will pay her more if she continues her attacks, or even feints in our direction.
I did not wish it to come to this; she is a distraction I can ill afford while I am busy with laying the groundwork for the future. But she is too disruptive if ignored, and so I must resort to extremes.
In a sense, I should be grateful to her for showing me the way. In a sense, it is good to know. Unlike the hooded hawk, I have never been content with being blind. I have always needed to know, to see.
But I can never forgive her for not letting me find it for myself. I would have; it would still be there without the knowledge or the vision or the certainty. She forced upon me what I knew already, and what I didn't need to know -- not yet. It would have been better to go step by step than to be pushed from a cliff.
There is only one person I have forgiven so far for that, and she is not he.